Apple’s new MagSafe charging system for the iPhone 12 and newer models offers some clear benefits over traditional wired Lightning charging. But Lightning still has its advantages too. So which iPhone charging method is better – MagSafe or Lightning?
There’s no definitive “winner” here – both options have tradeoffs across factors like speed, convenience, cost, and environmental impact. The best charging solution for you depends on your priorities and charging habits.
| Feature | MagSafe | Lightning |
|---|---|---|
| Maximum Charging Speed | 15W | 20W |
| Typical 0-50% Charge Time | ~1 hour | ~30 mins |
| Charging Convenience | High (magnetic alignment) | Moderate (cables can be inconvenient) |
| Innovative Accessories | Yes, magnetically attach | Limited |
| Cost of Accessories | More expensive | Cheaper cables |
| Environmental Impact | More e-waste due to extra material | Slightly less e-waste |
MagSafe Benefits Over Lightning
Convenience is a major selling point for MagSafe. The magnetic attachment system makes wireless charging effortless – just drop your iPhone onto the charger and it snaps into perfect alignment. No need to fiddle with cables or precisely position your phone.
MagSafe also enables neat accessories like magnetic mounts and wallets to snap right onto your iPhone. The MagSafe ecosystem keeps expanding too, so expect more innovative add-ons.
Faster wireless charging is another benefit. While MagSafe maxes out at 15W, it’s still faster than standard 5-7.5W Qi wireless charging. So if you want the ease of wireless without the slow speeds, MagSafe delivers.
Safety is also improved – MagSafe chargers detach easily if pulled, preventing accidents. And the magnetic alignment means foreign objects like credit cards won’t get stuck between the charger and iPhone, avoiding damage.
Lightning’s Advantages Over MagSafe
However, Lightning offers faster raw charging speeds, up to 20W with a compatible adapter versus MagSafe’s 15W. In practice, Lightning can charge an iPhone from 0-50% in 30 minutes, while MagSafe takes almost an hour.
The convenience aspects are subjective too. Some may prefer no wireless hassle at all with a Lightning cable they can use while moving around or lying in bed without a charging pad.
Costs are lower too – Lightning cables are cheaper than MagSafe accessories. And Lightning reuses existing chargers and cables, while MagSafe introduces new proprietary accessories.
Finally, Lightning produces less potential e-waste. However, MagSafe chargers are efficient and don’t overcharge iPhones, minimizing this issue ([7]).
It Depends On Your Needs
In the end, whether MagSafe or Lightning is better for charging your iPhone depends on your priorities:
- If you want maximum charging speed, Lightning is superior. But MagSafe is fast enough for most.
- If wireless convenience is important, MagSafe easily wins.
- If costs and waste reduction matter, Lightning has an edge.
- If new innovative accessories appeal to you, MagSafe is very promising.
My advice is to use Lightning cables for your bedside or travel charging needs to maximize speed and minimize costs (though there are some travel-friendly MagSafe chargers). Then add MagSafe chargers around your home for wireless convenience and flexibility.
The good news is you don’t necessarily have to choose – having both MagSafe and Lightning options gives you charging flexibility based on each situation. Apple made sure the iPhone 12 and newer models work great with both charging methods.
The Future is Wireless
While Lightning still holds some advantages today, it seems inevitable that MagSafe is the future for iPhone charging. Apple is clearly invested in this magnetic ecosystem, and wireless charging technology will only continue improving.
We expect MagSafe charging speeds, accessory innovation, and unique features to rival and eventually surpass Lightning over the next few iPhone generations. But for now, the choice between MagSafe vs Lightning comes down to your charging preferences – convenience or speed.
Hopefully this overview gives you a better sense of the MagSafe and Lightning tradeoffs. And helps you choose the best iPhone charging options for your needs, at least until MagSafe takes over completely!
